A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot (book) - Revision history

Sarfipour at 08:43, 15 April 2026

2026-04-15T08:43:16Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:43, 15 April 2026
Line 42:		Line 42:


	[[~~category~~:~~book review~~]]		[[Category:Bibliography Articles]]
	[[fa:جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل (کتاب)]]		[[fa:جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل (کتاب)]]
	[[Category:Books on Judicial Fiqh in Persian]]		[[Category:Books on Judicial Fiqh in Persian]]
	[[Category:Articles by Mehdi Sadeghi]]		[[Category:Articles by Mehdi Sadeghi]]

Sarfipour at 11:54, 6 March 2026

2026-03-06T11:54:30Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:54, 6 March 2026
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{Author		{{Author
	\|author = ~~Mahdi~~ Sadeghi		\|author = Mehdi Sadeghi
	\|author2 =		\|author2 =
	\|author3 =		\|author3 =

Sarfipour at 11:41, 6 March 2026

2026-03-06T11:41:20Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:41, 6 March 2026
Line 41:		Line 41:


	~~[[Category:Bibliographical Articles]]~~
	[[category:book review]]		[[category:book review]]
	[[fa:جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل (کتاب)]]		[[fa:جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل (کتاب)]]
	[[Category:Books on Judicial Fiqh in Persian]]		[[Category:Books on Judicial Fiqh in Persian]]
	[[Category:Articles by Mehdi Sadeghi]]		[[Category:Articles by Mehdi Sadeghi]]

Mkhaghanif at 13:14, 8 December 2025

2025-12-08T13:14:39Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 13:14, 8 December 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{Author		{{Author
	\|author = ~~Mehdi~~ Sadeghi		\|author = Mahdi Sadeghi
	\|author2 =		\|author2 =
	\|author3 =		\|author3 =

Sarfipour at 06:30, 6 December 2025

2025-12-06T06:30:45Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 06:30, 6 December 2025
Line 11:		Line 11:
	\| name = A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot		\| name = A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot
	\| image = A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot (book).jpg		\| image = A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot (book).jpg
	~~\| image_size =~~
	\| caption =		\| caption =
	\| ~~other_names~~ =		\| original_title = جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل
	\| author = Hosseinali Bina and Amir Hossein Fahimi		\| author = [[Hosseinali Bina]] and [[Amir Hossein Fahimi]]
	\| writing_date = 1401 SH		\| writing_date = 1401 SH
	\| topic = Criminal Jurisprudence		\| topic = Criminal Jurisprudence
	~~\| style =~~
	\| language = Persian		\| language = Persian
	~~\| editor =~~
	~~\| revised_by =~~
	~~\| compiled_by =~~
	~~\| illustrator =~~
	~~\| cover_designer =~~
	\| volumes = 1		\| volumes = 1
	\| pages = 101		\| pages = 101
	~~\| size =~~		\| publisher = Mirath-e Mandegar
	~~\| series =~~		\| publication_place = Qom
	~~\| translated_to =~~
	\| publisher = Mirath-e Mandegar\| publication_place = Qom
	\| publication_date = 1401 SH (c. 2022 CE)		\| publication_date = 1401 SH (c. 2022 CE)
	\| edition = First		\| edition = First
	~~\| circulation =~~		\| publication_details = Qom, Mirath-e Mandegar, 1401 SH.
	~~\| isbn =~~
	~~\| media_type =~~
	~~\| publisher_website =~~
	~~\| original_title = <!-- name of the book in Persian -->~~
	~~\| translator = <!-- translator to Persian -->~~
	\| publication_details = <!-~~- publication details in Persian -->~~
	~~\| electronic_version=~~
	~~\| other_volumes =~~
	}}		}}

Sarfipour at 05:38, 6 December 2025

2025-12-06T05:38:39Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:38, 6 December 2025
Line 57:		Line 57:
	In the final discourse, the authors examine important jurisprudential rules such as the rule of destruction (''qāʿidat al-itlāf''), the rule of dominion (''qāʿidat al-taslīṭ''), and the no-harm rule (''qāʿidat lā ḍarar''). This section also only explains the jurisprudential rules without specifying their relevance to the book's main topic. In addition to copying texts from jurisprudential books, in some cases, Arabic phrases have been added without any translation or explanation (pp. 72-101).		In the final discourse, the authors examine important jurisprudential rules such as the rule of destruction (''qāʿidat al-itlāf''), the rule of dominion (''qāʿidat al-taslīṭ''), and the no-harm rule (''qāʿidat lā ḍarar''). This section also only explains the jurisprudential rules without specifying their relevance to the book's main topic. In addition to copying texts from jurisprudential books, in some cases, Arabic phrases have been added without any translation or explanation (pp. 72-101).

	~~[[Category:Books on Judicial Fiqh in Persian]]~~
	[[Category:Bibliographical Articles]]		[[Category:Bibliographical Articles]]
	[[category:book review]]		[[category:book review]]
	[[fa:جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل (کتاب)]]		[[fa:جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل (کتاب)]]
			[[Category:Books on Judicial Fiqh in Persian]]
			[[Category:Articles by Mehdi Sadeghi]]

Sarfipour at 05:25, 6 December 2025

2025-12-06T05:25:30Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:25, 6 December 2025
Line 47:		Line 47:
	'''A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot''' (in Persian: [[:fa:جستاری_فقهی_در_ربات_انسان‌نمای_قاتل_(کتاب)\|جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل]]) is a book on [[Criminal Jurisprudence]] authored by Hosseinali Bina and Amir Hossein Fahimi, and published by Mirath-e Mandegar. The book is organized into five discourses and aims to provide a jurisprudential review of topics related to killer robots. However, the work is unedited and has a disjointed structure. The topics in its five discourses are presented independently without clarifying their connection to the main subject. Consequently, the book does not meet the reader's expectation for a comprehensive and analytical jurisprudential study of killer robots.		'''A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot''' (in Persian: [[:fa:جستاری_فقهی_در_ربات_انسان‌نمای_قاتل_(کتاب)\|جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل]]) is a book on [[Criminal Jurisprudence]] authored by Hosseinali Bina and Amir Hossein Fahimi, and published by Mirath-e Mandegar. The book is organized into five discourses and aims to provide a jurisprudential review of topics related to killer robots. However, the work is unedited and has a disjointed structure. The topics in its five discourses are presented independently without clarifying their connection to the main subject. Consequently, the book does not meet the reader's expectation for a comprehensive and analytical jurisprudential study of killer robots.

	~~=== Content~~ and ~~Critical Assessment ===~~		In the first discourse, the authors briefly outline the history of criminal law over two pages, analyzing it in three main stages: private revenge, private justice, and public justice. In the stage of private revenge, punishment was carried out by the victim or their family. In the stage of private justice, the state had limited oversight over the process of imposing punishment. But in the stage of public justice, the state took full responsibility for the administration of justice and punishment (pp. 11-12).
	~~The book's five discourses are presented as follows:~~

	~~==== Discourse 1: A Brief History of Criminal Law ====~~		The second discourse is dedicated to introducing killer robots and their various dimensions. In this section, the authors have copied several pages of reports from news agencies such as IRNA and the Young Journalists Club. Notably, the content from these sources is cited not directly but through non-authoritative third-party websites. This discourse examines the rapid advancement of [[artificial intelligence]] as the main factor increasing the likelihood of the emergence of killer robots and its transformation into a serious threat (pp. 14-22).
	In ~~the first discourse~~, the authors~~, in two~~ pages~~, outline the history~~ of the ~~periods of criminal law, analyzing it in three main stages: private revenge, private justice, and public justice~~. ~~In the stage of private revenge~~, ~~punishment was carried out by~~ the ~~victim or their family~~. In the ~~stage~~ of ~~private justice,~~ the ~~state had limited oversight over the process of imposing punishment. But in~~ the ~~stage~~ of ~~public justice, the state took full responsibility for~~ the ~~administration~~ of ~~justice~~ and ~~punishment~~ (pp. 11-12).

	~~==== Discourse 2: Introduction to Killer Robots ====~~		In the third discourse, the authors explain fundamental concepts related to the research, such as robot, programming, free will, coercion, [[Muharabah\|muḥārabah]], responsibility, and murder. Here too, content has been copied from books like ''Āyāt al-Aḥkām'' (written by [[Abbasali Amid Zanjani]]) and ''Aḥkām-i Ḥuqūqī-yi Islām'' (written by Nematollah Yousefian), without adequate explanation (pp. 25-45).
	~~The second~~ discourse ~~introduces killer robots by uncritically reproducing several pages of reports from news agencies like IRNA. Notably~~, the ~~content is cited not from~~ the ~~original sources but through unreliable third-party websites~~. ~~However~~, ~~the~~ content ~~from these two sites~~ has been ~~cited not directly, but through non~~-~~authoritative websites. This discourse examines the rapid advancement of~~ [[~~artificial intelligence~~]] ~~as the main factor increasing the likelihood of the emergence of killer robots~~ and ~~its transformation into a serious threat~~ (pp. 14-22).

	~~==== '''Discourse 3: Fundamental Concepts''' ====~~		The fourth discourse presents a brief translation and interpretation of Quranic verses related to murder. It merely lists the relevant verses and offers a general interpretation, but the authors do not explain the connection of this exegetical content to the main topic of the book. Most of the exegetical material is also not from jurisprudential or authoritative sources (pp. 46-71).
	In the ~~third discourse~~, the authors explain ~~fundamental concepts and topics related~~ to the ~~research, such as robot, programming, free will, coercion, [[muharabah]], responsibility, and murder~~. ~~In this section as well, content has been copied~~ from ~~books like Ayat al-Ahkam (written by [[Abbasali Amid Zanjani]]) and Ahkam-e Hoquqi-ye Eslam (written by Nematollah Yousefian), and no adequate explanation has been provided~~ (pp. 25-45).

	~~====~~ '''~~Discourse 4: Quranic Verses on Murder~~''' ~~====~~		In the final discourse, the authors examine important jurisprudential rules such as the rule of destruction (''qāʿidat al-itlāf''), the rule of dominion (''qāʿidat al-taslīṭ''), and the no-harm rule (''qāʿidat lā ḍarar''). This section also only explains the jurisprudential rules without specifying their relevance to the book's main topic. In addition to copying texts from jurisprudential books, in some cases, Arabic phrases have been added without any translation or explanation (pp. 72-101).
	~~In the fourth discourse~~, ~~a brief translation~~ and ~~interpretation of verses related to murder are presented~~. This ~~discourse~~ only ~~lists verses related to murder and confines itself to a general interpretation of these verses, and~~ the ~~authors have not explained the connection of this exegetical content~~ to the main topic ~~of the book~~. ~~Most of the exegetical content is also not~~ from jurisprudential or ~~authoritative books~~ (pp. 46-71).

	~~==== '''Discourse 5: Jurisprudential Rules''' ====~~
	In the final discourse, the authors examine important jurisprudential rules such as the rule of destruction (qa'idat al-itlaf), the rule of dominion (qa'idat al-taslit), and the rule of no harm (qa'idat la darar).

	~~==== '''Critical Weaknesses in Structure and Content''' ====~~
	In this discourse as well, only an explanation of the jurisprudential rules is mentioned, but the connection of these rules to the main topic of the book is not specified. In this section, in addition to copying texts from jurisprudential books, in some cases, Arabic phrases have been added without any translation or explanation (pp. 72-101).
	[[Category:Books on Judicial Fiqh in Persian]]		[[Category:Books on Judicial Fiqh in Persian]]
	[[Category:Bibliographical Articles]]		[[Category:Bibliographical Articles]]
	[[category:book review]]		[[category:book review]]
	[[fa:جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل (کتاب)]]		[[fa:جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل (کتاب)]]

Sarfipour at 05:04, 6 December 2025

2025-12-06T05:04:52Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:04, 6 December 2025
Line 45:		Line 45:
	* '''Abstract'''		* '''Abstract'''

	'''A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot''' (Persian: ''[[:fa:جستاری_فقهی_در_ربات_انسان‌نمای_قاتل_(کتاب)\|جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل ~~(کتاب~~)]]~~''),~~ by Hosseinali Bina and Amir Hossein Fahimi, ~~is a work in [[Criminal Jurisprudence]]~~. The book aims to review ~~the topic~~ of killer robots ~~but~~ is ~~critically flawed by a lack of editing~~ and a disjointed structure. ~~Its~~ five discourses ~~present disconnected topics—copied from uncredited or non-authoritative sources—without establishing any clear relevance~~ to the ~~central theme~~. ~~Ultimately~~, the ~~work fails to provide~~ the comprehensive, analytical jurisprudential ~~examination its title promises~~.		'''A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot''' (in Persian: [[:fa:جستاری_فقهی_در_ربات_انسان‌نمای_قاتل_(کتاب)\|جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل]]) is a book on [[Criminal Jurisprudence]] authored by Hosseinali Bina and Amir Hossein Fahimi, and published by Mirath-e Mandegar. The book is organized into five discourses and aims to provide a jurisprudential review of topics related to killer robots. However, the work is unedited and has a disjointed structure. The topics in its five discourses are presented independently without clarifying their connection to the main subject. Consequently, the book does not meet the reader's expectation for a comprehensive and analytical jurisprudential study of killer robots.

	=== Content and Critical Assessment ===		=== Content and Critical Assessment ===

Sarfipour at 04:55, 6 December 2025

2025-12-06T04:55:24Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:55, 6 December 2025
Line 45:		Line 45:
	* '''Abstract'''		* '''Abstract'''

	'''A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot''' (Persian: ''~~Justārī Fiqhī dar Rubāt-i Insān’namā-yi Qātil~~''), by Hosseinali Bina and Amir Hossein Fahimi, is a work in [[Criminal Jurisprudence]]. The book aims to review the topic of killer robots but is critically flawed by a lack of editing and a disjointed structure. Its five discourses present disconnected topics—copied from uncredited or non-authoritative sources—without establishing any clear relevance to the central theme. Ultimately, the work fails to provide the comprehensive, analytical jurisprudential examination its title promises.		'''A Jurisprudential Inquiry into the Killer Humanoid Robot''' (Persian: ''[[:fa:جستاری_فقهی_در_ربات_انسان‌نمای_قاتل_(کتاب)\|جستاری فقهی در ربات انسان‌نمای قاتل (کتاب)]]''), by Hosseinali Bina and Amir Hossein Fahimi, is a work in [[Criminal Jurisprudence]]. The book aims to review the topic of killer robots but is critically flawed by a lack of editing and a disjointed structure. Its five discourses present disconnected topics—copied from uncredited or non-authoritative sources—without establishing any clear relevance to the central theme. Ultimately, the work fails to provide the comprehensive, analytical jurisprudential examination its title promises.

	=== Content and Critical Assessment ===		=== Content and Critical Assessment ===

Sarfipour at 04:40, 6 December 2025

2025-12-06T04:40:48Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:40, 6 December 2025
Line 29:		Line 29:
	\| series =		\| series =
	\| translated_to =		\| translated_to =
	\| publisher = ~~Miras~~-e Mandegar		\| publisher = Mirath-e Mandegar\| publication_place = Qom
	\| publication_place = Qom
	\| publication_date = 1401 SH (c. 2022 CE)		\| publication_date = 1401 SH (c. 2022 CE)
	\| edition = First		\| edition = First