A study of the Arguments and Jurisprudential Rulings on Artificial Insemination From the Perspectives of Imamiya and Sunni Jurisprudence (Book): Difference between revisions
| Line 63: | Line 63: | ||
According to the author, Islamic jurists such as [[Mahmud Shaltut]], Ahmed Mohamed Ahmed Al-Tayyib, Sheikh Mansur, Sheikh Mustafa Zarqa, and several other Sunni jurists consider artificial insemination using the eggs and sperm of a married couple to be permissible. In contrast, some jurists, including Sheikh Rajab Bayoudh Al-Tamimi, Sheikh Muhammad Sharif Ahmed, Sheikh Abdulaziz bin Abdullah bin Baz, and Sheikh Abu Bakr Abu Zaid, deem it to be prohibited (pp. 90-92). | According to the author, Islamic jurists such as [[Mahmud Shaltut]], Ahmed Mohamed Ahmed Al-Tayyib, Sheikh Mansur, Sheikh Mustafa Zarqa, and several other Sunni jurists consider artificial insemination using the eggs and sperm of a married couple to be permissible. In contrast, some jurists, including Sheikh Rajab Bayoudh Al-Tamimi, Sheikh Muhammad Sharif Ahmed, Sheikh Abdulaziz bin Abdullah bin Baz, and Sheikh Abu Bakr Abu Zaid, deem it to be prohibited (pp. 90-92). | ||
== | == AI Using Donor Gametes == | ||
Another form of artificial insemination involves the use of the egg or sperm from a woman and a man who do not share a marital bond. The author indicates that the sensitivity in this instance is particularly significant when the sperm from a non-related male is inserted into the wife’s womb, and the majority of the arguments are directed towards this particular case (p. 44). | Another form of artificial insemination involves the use of the egg or sperm from a woman and a man who do not share a marital bond. The author indicates that the sensitivity in this instance is particularly significant when the sperm from a non-related male is inserted into the wife’s womb, and the majority of the arguments are directed towards this particular case (p. 44). | ||
===Shia jurisprudence=== | ===Shia jurisprudence=== | ||