Sculpture: Difference between revisions
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
Additionally, Ja’far Sobhani asserts that the statements of Abul Salah Halabi<ref>15. Halabi, Al-Kafi fi al-Fiqh, p. 281.</ref> and Ibn Barraj<ref>16. Ibn Barraj, Al-Muhadhab, Vol. 1, p. 344.</ref>, regarding the impermissibility of creating sculptures apply even to sculptures of non-living beings<ref>17. Ya'qoubi Isfahani, Al-Mawahib fi Tahreer Maksab al-Muharramah, p. 377.</ref>. | Additionally, Ja’far Sobhani asserts that the statements of Abul Salah Halabi<ref>15. Halabi, Al-Kafi fi al-Fiqh, p. 281.</ref> and Ibn Barraj<ref>16. Ibn Barraj, Al-Muhadhab, Vol. 1, p. 344.</ref>, regarding the impermissibility of creating sculptures apply even to sculptures of non-living beings<ref>17. Ya'qoubi Isfahani, Al-Mawahib fi Tahreer Maksab al-Muharramah, p. 377.</ref>. | ||
== Fatwas and Reasons for Prohibition and its Exceptions == | == Fatwas and Reasons for Prohibition and its Exceptions == | ||
According to Sheikh Ansari, the prohibition of crafting sculptures of living beings is generally accepted among Shi’a jurists<ref>18. Sheikh Ansari, Kitab al-Makasib, Vol. 14, p. 183.</ref>, a view also embraced by Sunni scholars, as stated by [[Sayyid Abolqassem Musavi Khoei]]<ref> Tohidi Tabrizi, Misbah al-Fiqhaheh, Vol. 1, p. 353.</ref>. Among contemporaries, jurists such as Sayyid Abolqassem Musavi Khoei<ref>20. Khoei, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 262.</ref>, [[Sayyid Ali Sistani]]<ref>21. Sistani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 423.</ref>, Sayyid Ruhollah Khomeini<ref>22. Khomeini, Tahreer al-Wasilah, Vol. 1, p. 472.</ref>, [[Mohammad Ishaq Fayaz]]<ref>23. Fayyaz, Al-Istifta'at al-Shar'iyyah, Vol. 2, p. 13.</ref>, [[Sayyid Mousa Shubairi Zanjani]]<ref>24. Shobeiri Zanjani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 80.</ref>, [[Naser Makarem Shirazi]]<ref>25. Makarem Shirazi, Istifta'at Jadid, Vol. 1, p. 158.</ref>, and [[ | According to Sheikh Ansari, the prohibition of crafting sculptures of living beings is generally accepted among Shi’a jurists<ref>18. Sheikh Ansari, Kitab al-Makasib, Vol. 14, p. 183.</ref>, a view also embraced by Sunni scholars, as stated by [[Sayyid Abolqassem Musavi Khoei]]<ref> Tohidi Tabrizi, Misbah al-Fiqhaheh, Vol. 1, p. 353.</ref>. Among contemporaries, jurists such as Sayyid Abolqassem Musavi Khoei<ref>20. Khoei, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 262.</ref>, [[Sayyid Ali Sistani]]<ref>21. Sistani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 423.</ref>, Sayyid Ruhollah Khomeini<ref>22. Khomeini, Tahreer al-Wasilah, Vol. 1, p. 472.</ref>, [[Mohammad Ishaq Fayaz]]<ref>23. Fayyaz, Al-Istifta'at al-Shar'iyyah, Vol. 2, p. 13.</ref>, [[Sayyid Mousa Shubairi Zanjani]]<ref>24. Shobeiri Zanjani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 80.</ref>, [[Naser Makarem Shirazi]]<ref>25. Makarem Shirazi, Istifta'at Jadid, Vol. 1, p. 158.</ref>, and [[Lotfollah Safi Golpaygani]]<ref>26. Safi Golpaygani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 409.</ref> have all deemed crafting sculptures of living beings, such as humans and animals, as prohibited. | ||
=== Evidence of Prohibition === | === Evidence of Prohibition === | ||
| Line 53: | Line 53: | ||
2. Sayyid Ruhollah Khomeini: If a sculpture is made using machinery, it is not considered prohibited because the evidence for the prohibition of sculpture only applies to cases where an individual manually creates sculptures<ref>Makarem Shirazi, Istifta'at Jadid, Vol. 3, p. 168.</ref>. | 2. Sayyid Ruhollah Khomeini: If a sculpture is made using machinery, it is not considered prohibited because the evidence for the prohibition of sculpture only applies to cases where an individual manually creates sculptures<ref>Makarem Shirazi, Istifta'at Jadid, Vol. 3, p. 168.</ref>. | ||
3. [[Sayyid Abolqassem Musavi Khoei]], | 3. [[Sayyid Abolqassem Musavi Khoei]], [[Lotfollah Safi Golpaygani]], and [[Ja’far Sobhani]]: Creating incomplete or partial sculptures of humans and other animals is permissible. However, Lotfollah Safi Golpaygani deems crafting a sculpture that includes major parts such as the head, face, and chest as problematic, adding that crafting sculptures of hands, feet, or heads alone is not problematic<ref>Khomeini, Al-Makasib al-Muharramah, Vol. 2, p. 177.</ref>. | ||
| Line 74: | Line 75: | ||
In addition to discussing the fundamental ruling on sculpture, jurists have also addressed related topics such as the “keeping, buying and selling of sculptures” and “destroying sculptures.” | In addition to discussing the fundamental ruling on sculpture, jurists have also addressed related topics such as the “keeping, buying and selling of sculptures” and “destroying sculptures.” | ||
=== Keeping, Buying, and Selling Sculptures: === | === Keeping, Buying, and Selling Sculptures: === | ||
Most jurists have considered buying, selling, and keeping sculptures, even those depicting living beings, as permissible<ref>Tabrizi, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 358.</ref>. According to Khoei, the available evidence only indicates the prohibition of sculpture making, and there is no evidence prohibiting its keeping, buying, and selling<ref>51. For example, see Khoei, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 356; Tohidi Tabrizi, Misbah al-Fuqaheh, Vol. 1, p. 382; Sistani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 423; Khomeini, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 275; Vahid Khorasani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 582; Fazel Lankarani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 395; Shobeiri Zanjani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 80.</ref>. Among contemporary jurists, figures like | Most jurists have considered buying, selling, and keeping sculptures, even those depicting living beings, as permissible<ref>Tabrizi, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 358.</ref>. According to Khoei, the available evidence only indicates the prohibition of sculpture making, and there is no evidence prohibiting its keeping, buying, and selling<ref>51. For example, see Khoei, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 356; Tohidi Tabrizi, Misbah al-Fuqaheh, Vol. 1, p. 382; Sistani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 423; Khomeini, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 275; Vahid Khorasani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 582; Fazel Lankarani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 395; Shobeiri Zanjani, Tawzih al-Masa'il, p. 80.</ref>. Among contemporary jurists, figures like [[Lotfollah Safi Golpaygani]] and Naser Makarem Shirazi have deemed buying, selling, and owning sculptures of living beings, earning a living out of it and earning wages by making sculptures as prohibited<ref> Tohidi Tabrizi, Misbah al-Fuqaheh, Vol. 1, p. 240.</ref>. Sheikh Ansari considers keeping, buying, and selling sculptures of living beings as disliked (makruh)<ref>Sheikh Ansari, Kitab al-Makasib, Vol. 1, p. 197.</ref>. | ||
=== Destroying Sculptures: === | === Destroying Sculptures: === | ||
According to Alireza A’rafi, while explicit statements from early scholars regarding the prohibition to keep sculptures or the obligation to destroy them are not found, some jurists' statements can be interpreted to imply this obligation<ref>Abidinzadeh, Mujassameh wa Naqqashi: Taqrirat-e Dars-e Ayatollah A’arafi, p. 552.</ref>. The evidence that may indicate the obligation to destroy sculptures and the prohibition to keep them include: | According to Alireza A’rafi, while explicit statements from early scholars regarding the prohibition to keep sculptures or the obligation to destroy them are not found, some jurists' statements can be interpreted to imply this obligation<ref>Abidinzadeh, Mujassameh wa Naqqashi: Taqrirat-e Dars-e Ayatollah A’arafi, p. 552.</ref>. The evidence that may indicate the obligation to destroy sculptures and the prohibition to keep them include: | ||