Yousef Saanei: Difference between revisions

M.zandi (talk | contribs)
M.zandi (talk | contribs)
Line 81: Line 81:


== Critics and Opponents ==
== Critics and Opponents ==
The specific jurisprudential fatwas of Yousef Saanei have drawn widespread criticism. The Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom, following a question regarding his Marja'iyyah, wrote: "The Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom, based on investigations conducted over the past year and after numerous meetings, has reached the conclusion that he lacks the necessary criteria for occupying the position of Marja'iyyah."<ref>[https://jameehmodarresin.org/1139/849/ “Opinion of the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom regarding the Marja'iyyah of Mr. Hajj Shaykh Yousef Saanei”], Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom.</ref> At the same time, the Farda website claimed it had inquired about the opinions of other Maraja' offices regarding Yousef Saanei's Marja'iyyah; in this regard, the office of the Supreme Leader reminded of the need to refer to one of the Maraja' without an explicit answer, while other Maraja' offices did not consider the issuance of this statement sufficient to disqualify him from Marja'iyyah.<ref>Opinions of the Maraja' Offices regarding the followers of Ayatollah Sa'anei, Khabar Online.</ref> The Assembly of Teachers and Researchers of the Qom Seminary also issued a statement expressing regret over this action.<ref>[http://majmaqom.ir/بیانیه-ها-و-اطلاعیه-ها/99 “Number 99: The Status of Marja'iyyah in the Seminaries”], Website of the Assembly of Teachers and Researchers of the Qom Seminary.</ref>
There has been widespread criticism of the specific fatwas of Yousef Saanei. The Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom stated in response to a question regarding his religious authority: "based on investigations conducted over the past year and numerous sessions, The Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom has concluded that he lacks the necessary criteria to be a religious authority."<ref>[https://jameehmodarresin.org/1139/849/ “Opinion of the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom regarding the Marja'iyyah of Mr. Hajj Shaykh Yousef Saanei”], Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom.</ref> At the same time, the Farda website claimed that they had inquired about the opinions of other Maraji' offices about Marja'iyyah of Yousef Saanei, and none of them considered this statement sufficient to disqualify him from Marja'iyyah in this regard, and the office of the Supreme Leader had not answered explicitly and had refered to one of the other Maraji'.<ref>Opinions of the Maraja' Offices regarding the followers of Ayatollah Sa'anei, Khabar Online.</ref> The Assembly of Teachers and Researchers of the Qom Seminary also issued a statement expressing regret over this action.<ref>[http://majmaqom.ir/بیانیه-ها-و-اطلاعیه-ها/99 “Number 99: The Status of Marja'iyyah in the Seminaries”], Website of the Assembly of Teachers and Researchers of the Qom Seminary.</ref>


Books and articles have been written in criticism of Yousef Saanei's jurisprudential views, including:
Books and articles have been written in criticism of Yousef Saanei's jurisprudential views, including: